Homemade Butterfingers

CandyBar Week1 Homemade Butterfingers

We’re now on day number 2 of our CandyBar Week here at Pennywise Cook. It’s great making cakes and cookies and casseroles and all, but there is great satisfaction that comes when you have a batch of homemade candybars laying around. I’ve been using them for more than just eating by themselves. I’ve thrown a few in homemade ice cream a couple of times. They also make great bribery tools for the kids. And the husband…

Homemade Butterfingers 6 Homemade Butterfingers

Today’s homemade candybar is Butterfinger! Oh yeah, that’s right. Peanut Buttery, orange goodness. You might just be surprised by what exactly goes into these.

It’s possible that you may need to have a seat before you continue reading.

Almost everyone that tasted these could not guess what it was that these are made of. But they ALL said they taste exactly like the real thing.

Homemade Butterfingers 1 Homemade Butterfingers

It all starts with the famous fall candy, candy corn. I’m a big fan of it myself, but just like coconut I know there are some who don’t like it. It doesn’t matter. If they like Butterfingers, they will like your candybars even though they contain candy corn. If you’re concerned about whether that will make a difference, just don’t tell them. It can be our little secret.

But you might just be dying to share this 3-INGREDIENT recipe with everyone.

It starts with 1 pound of candy corn getting all smooth and melty in the microwave. I was a little surprised, but this was my first experience melting candy corn. It was fun. I was surprised at how quick it went back to being firm again.

Homemade Butterfingers 2 Homemade Butterfingers

Here’s a view of the melted candy corn awaiting the arrival of peanut butter. That’s the next step once you get it melted. Stir in a 16 oz jar of creamy peanut butter.

Homemade Butterfingers 3 Homemade Butterfingers

Then it’s time to pour it into a square pan to freeze. I used another piece of wax paper to smooth the top out and create a perfect square. I didn’t freeze it with the wax paper on top.

Homemade Butterfingers 4 Homemade Butterfingers

No need to freeze it long. Just let it get firm for about 15 minutes. You’ll find that the candy corn really firms up well.

Cut it into squares. You decide how big. Just eyeball it. I tried to make mine smaller so I could eat more. icon smile Homemade Butterfingers

Homemade Butterfingers 5 Homemade Butterfingers

Then it’s all a matter of using two forks to roll the squares through melted chocolate wafers. When I started, mine were really ugly y’all. But as I went on, I got better and they began to look fairly similar to a candybar. I even used my fork to drizzle little lines on the top to mimic the real thing. Not perfect, but I think it was a nice touch.

Homemade Butterfingers 7 Homemade Butterfingers

And they turned out SO good! They taste so incredibly similar that it’s crazy. I was very impressed with them and I know you will be too!

Let me know if you make them!

Recipe adapted from Plain Chicken.

5.0 from 2 reviews

Homemade Butterfingers
Author: 
Recipe type: Dessert, Candy, Snacks
 

With just 3 simple ingredients, you can create your very own Butterfinger candybars!
Ingredients
  • 1 Pound Candy Corn
  • 16 oz Jar Creamy Peanut Butter
  • 2 Cups Chocolate Wafer Melts

Instructions
  1. Melt candy corn in the microwave on high for 1 minute. Stir then continue microwaving in 15-second increments until melted completely. Stir between each interval.
  2. Stir in the peanut butter until smooth. Pour into a lined or greased 8×8 square baking dish. Freeze for about 10 minutes. Place wax paper onto a cookie sheet.
  3. Cut into small squares. Melt chocolate wafers according to package. Using two fork, roll the square into chocolate coating all sides. Lay on wax paper and allow to firm. Freeze for about 10 minutes once all are coated.

This post may contain affiliate links. You can read more about this in my disclosure policy.

Like this post? SHARE it!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Comments

  1. Michelle says:

    Hi! Thanks for the Butterfinger recipe. I’m looking forward to trying it sometime. Where you wrote not to disclose the secret ingredient to people who don’t like candy corn, I was hoping that you could stick something in there like, (unless they’re vegetarian), because candy corn contains gelatin.

    • amy says:

      Thanks Michelle! I didn’t even realize gelatin was in candy corn. You learn something new everyday! Thanks for pointing it out. :)

      I removed your last name from your comment. :)

      Amy

  2. Wow says:

    Also, can you delete that comment after you read it? I didn’t know my full name would be displayed.

  3. Brittany says:

    This is an amazing recipe. I work in a nursing home and one of the nurses I work with made this and I never thought that candy corn, peanut butter and chocolate would taste good together :)

Trackbacks

  1. [...] I used a fork to turn and coat them well. These were a little more difficult to work with than the Butterfingers. These didn’t turn out as pretty for me, but they were still [...]

Speak Your Mind

*

Rate this recipe: